"It was all in front of me, but I didn’t have another solution, and so I kept pressing forward." - Ken Woodward
"It was all in front of me, but I didn’t have another solution, and so I kept pressing forward.” - Ken Woodward
I was brought in to save a Navy program, and years later I was the one building the slides recommending we kill it. In part two of this look at critical thinking, I ask why capable thinking often fails to change what I do.
On an unmanned minehunting program, I felt a doubt about tow cables, explained it away with true things, and kept pressing forward, because I didn’t have another solution. A rotation to the Pentagon gave me a second bearing.
By the time I reached my next program, I had built a team where I could doubt out loud. With mines in the Strait of Hormuz making the need real, I look at escalation of commitment, identity, and orders, and at what it takes to keep a doubt open until it gets an answer.
The question I’m carrying this week: What have I felt, and then explained away?
This Curated Questions episode can be found on all major platforms and at CuratedQuestions.com.
Be sure to subscribe to the weekly Curated Questions Dispatch newsletter for more fun with questions and curiosity! (https://substack.com/@curatedquestions)
Keep questioning!
Episode Notes
00:00 Pressing Forward
02:01 Two AM On Deck
02:25 A Desk Far Away
03:07 Part Two Setup
03:30 From Subs To Mines
04:07 Why Mine Hunting Matters
04:24 The Refrigerator Problem
05:15 Mines Are Real
05:35 Hormuz Uncertainty
06:34 Not About The War
06:56 Need Makes Doubt Easy
07:07 Nunn McCurdy Rescue
08:01 How Acquisition Works
08:37 Defending A Hated Program
09:08 Progress And The Pitch
09:43 Critical Thinking Aimed Wrong
10:01 Orders And Assumptions
10:49 Tow Cable Doubt
12:16 No Alternative Trap
13:16 Aporia And Discomfort
14:32 Second Bearing Change Seats
14:58 Pentagon Perspective Shift
16:12 Converted To Cancel
17:35 No Questions Left
18:24 Escalation Of Commitment
20:56 Knifefish And Doubt Out Loud
25:19 Resist Then Persist