"Disagreement makes the map visible. Agreement lets it pass for the terrain." - Ken Woodward
"Disagreement makes the map visible. Agreement lets it pass for the terrain." - Ken Woodward
"Thank you for your service" arrives with a script already written. A World War II veteran taught Ken Woodward a better reply: "You were worth it." That exchange opens a solo episode about the worlds hidden inside the questions we answer.
Ken starts with a single verb that put broken glass on a road where there was none, then turns to survey research showing how answer choices define normal, and to philosopher R.G. Collingwood's idea that every question stands on assumptions. From there he returns to the streets of Washington, D.C., sorting the questions strangers asked his "Black and Brown Lives Matter" sign by the maps they carried, including the ones pointing back at the sign itself.
The hardest case comes last: a question Ken agreed with, never examined, and what his nod cost the conversation. Disagreement makes the map visible. Agreement lets it pass for the terrain.
What world did you agree to before you answered?
This Curated Questions episode can be found on all major platforms and at CuratedQuestions.com.
Be sure to subscribe to the weekly Curated Questions Dispatch newsletter for more fun with questions and curiosity! (https://substack.com/@curatedquestions)
Keep questioning!
Episode Notes
00:00 Making The Map Visible
01:57 You Were Worth It
03:16 Questions Carry Worlds
03:44 The Question Assumed
04:20 Smashed Versus Hit
05:21 Broken Glass Memory
06:20 Answer Choices Shape Norms
07:27 Absolute Presuppositions
08:50 Ordinary Hidden Assumptions
10:04 A Habit Before Answering
10:25 Walking DC With A Sign
11:05 Are You Doing Penance
12:11 Why Do You Care
13:57 Who Is Brown
15:36 What About White Lives
17:50 The Question I Agreed With
18:10 How God Bless America Maps
21:56 Choosing Which World
24:16 The Closing Question
25:28 Wisdom Revisited